US Supreme Court rules in favor of anti-abortion organization in New Jersey News
MarkThomas / Pixabay
US Supreme Court rules in favor of anti-abortion organization in New Jersey

The US Supreme Court sided with a Christian faith-based crisis pregnancy center in New Jersey on Wednesday. The pregnancy center, First Choice Women’s Resource Centers, was attempting to curb a state investigation into its activities.

All Supreme Court justices unanimously reversed a lower court’s decision, ruling in favor of First Choice in a federal lawsuit. First Choice had previously filed suit challenging the constitutionality of a 2023 subpoena initiated by New Jersey State Attorney General Matthew Platkin. The subpoena sought information regarding the center’s donors and doctors, demanding the identities of the organization’s financial supporters. The lower court had previously dismissed the case due to the group “failing to state a justiciable claim.”

The case is now remanded to a lower court. In the opinion, the Court held:

Since the 1950s, this Court has confronted one official demand after another, like the Attorney General’s. Over and again, we have held those demands burden the exercise of First Amendment rights. Disputing none of these precedents but seeking ways around them, the Attorney General has offered a variety of arguments. Some are old, some are new, but none succeeds.

The First Choice centers seek to discourage women from having abortions. The state investigation was grounded in uncovering whether the organization misrepresented its services to donors and clients alike by portraying that it offers abortions and other services. However, the issue before the Supreme Court was simply whether the state-issued subpoena was unconstitutional. The religious organization claims that the subpoena has a chilling effect on the group’s First Amendment rights to free speech and association.

After Roe v. Wade was overturned in 2022, Platkin issued a consumer alert warning that crisis pregnancy centers do not offer abortion services and “may also provide false or misleading information about abortion.” This concern led to a further investigation of First Choice and the subsequent subpoena.

The American Civil Liberties Union of New Jersey celebrated this decision in a press release. The organization stated that nonprofits are now able to seek immediate federal review of state subpoenas that may impede constitutional protections.

THIS DAY @ LAW

Memphis Massacre of 1866 breaks out

The Memphis Massacre of 1866 broke out on May 1 of that year after Black Union veterans and police were involved in an altercation surrounding the arrest of a Black soldier. The ensuing skirmish spiralled out of control due to the racial tensions that followed the end of the US Civil War, lasting for two days and claiming the lives of 46 Black people and six whites.  The riot later cemented support for what would become the Fourteenth Amendment to the US Consitution, ensuring equal protection under the law. Learn more about the Memphis Massacre.  

Acts of Union creates Great Britain

On May 1, 1707, the two Acts of Union went into effect, implementing the Treaty of Union and thereby uniting the Kingdom of England and the Kingdom of Scotland to create the United Kingdom of Great Britain. The Union with Scotland Act was passed by the Parliament of England in 1706, and the Scottish Parliament promulgated the Union with England Act. Learn more about the Acts of Union from the Parliament of the United Kingdom.

First US trade union formed

On May 1, 1794, the Federal Society of Journeymen Cordwainers (shoemakers) was organized in Philadelphia to negotiate wages for its members, becoming the first trade union in the United States. Learn more about the history of the labor movement in the United States, and visit the website of the AFL-CIO, the federation of America's labor unions, representing more than 13 million workers.