JURIST Digital Scholars
Apple appeals Tokyo court ruling for Samsung
Apple appeals Tokyo court ruling for Samsung
Photo source or description

[JURIST] Apple [corporate website] on Monday appealed a Tokyo District Court [official website, in Japanese] ruling which dismissed Apple’s claim that Samsung [corporate website] had infringed on Apple’s patents. The appeal [Bloomberg report] comes after Judge Tamotsu Shoji ruled in August that Samsung did not violate [JURIST report] Apple’s patents for inventions allowing smart phones and tablets to synchronize music and video data with servers. The court subsequently dismissed Apple’s claim for USD $1.3 million in damages along with its request for an injunction to block the sale of eight Samsung products in Japan. As a result of the dismissal, Apple was ordered to pay Samsung’s litigation costs.

Apple’s appeal is the most recent event in a protracted patent litigation battle [JURIST op-ed] with Samsung that spans four continents. The Tokyo court handed down its August ruling after Apple won a USD $1.05 billion judgment [JURIST report; video] against Samsung in late August in the US District Court for the Northern District of California [official website]. The dispute covered everything from the shape and design of the competing companies’ tablets and smartphones to the technology employed in the devices’ software interface. Further, a South Korean court held in mid-August that the technology companies had violated [JURIST report] each others’ patents and banned sales of several products in the country. In July a UK court held that Samsung tablets did not infringe on Apple’s patents, and earlier in July a federal judge enjoined [JURIST reports] Samsung to stop sales of its Galaxy Nexus smartphone in the US. Apple in April of last year filed [JURIST report] the original suit alleging that Samsung had violated 10 patents, two trademarks and two trade dresses by copying iPhone and iPad technology in the making of its “Galaxy” products.