Interview: 35 years after Timor-Leste’s Santa Cruz massacre, families still search for their dead Features
Mark Rhomberg/ETAN, Attribution, via Wikimedia Commons
Interview: 35 years after Timor-Leste’s Santa Cruz massacre, families still search for their dead

Editor’s note: Thursday marks 35 years since Indonesian troops opened fire on pro-independence demonstrators in Dili. Scholar Lia Kent explains why state commemorations haven’t ended many families’ search for their dead.

November 12 of this year marks 35 years since the brutal murder of around 250 to 271 peaceful, pro-independence demonstrators in East Timor (the exact figures remain disputed) by Indonesian military forces, an event the world came to know as the Santa Cruz massacre. Also known as the Dili massacre, the killings were filmed by foreign journalists, whose footage of Indonesian troops opening fire on the crowd drew international outrage, put intense diplomatic pressure on Indonesia, and helped shatter the secrecy that Indonesia’s 1975 invasion had imposed by preventing independent movement in the country, ultimately contributing to Timor-Leste’s independence in 2002.

JURIST’s Sarisha Harikrishna spoke with Dr Lia Kent, who is an Associate Professor and Vice Chancellor’s Principal Research and Impact Fellow in the Institute for Sustainable Industries and Liveable Cities (ISILC) at Victoria University, Australia. Dr Kent’s work  focuses on peacebuilding, memory politics and transitional justice in the years following the Indonesian occupation. Her research has culminated in the publication of multiple widely regarded works, most notably her book The Dynamics of Transitional Justice: International Models and Local Realities in East Timor (2012) and The Unruly Dead: Spirits, Memory, and State Formation in Timor-Leste (2024).

Her research demonstrates the gap between official remembrance of the Santa Cruz massacre and the intimate, unsettled work of grieving. She argues that state commemoration alone cannot produce a genuine reckoning with the violence of the past. By focusing on families’ practices of searching for the remains of loved ones, performing death rituals, and demanding action from the state, she suggests that remembering the Santa Cruz dead is not simply an archival exercise or a celebration of nationalism; it is part of the continuing struggle over how atrocities are remembered, understood and addressed. 

JURIST: In The Unruly Dead, you argue the dead are “active, and sometimes disruptive, participants” in state building. But in The Dynamics of Transitional Justice, you showed how easily the state took victims’ stories and folded them into a “Timorese struggle” myth. Can the dead really disrupt that, or does the state always find a way to absorb them in the end?

Professor Kent: That’s a fantastic question. I think we need to keep asking it, because there’s no straightforward answer. What I see is that the state is always trying to absorb the dead into the national narrative, to enfold them into the story of how Timor-Leste became an independent state. And Timor-Leste is not alone – all states try to absorb the dead, at least those dead bodies that are convenient to the telling of a nationalist story. As I discuss in the book [The Unruly Dead], the Timor-Leste state does this by creating “Garden of Heroes cemeteries” to valorize the dead. Deceased former resistance members are now buried in Gardens of Heroes cemeteries around the country, and the state also absorbs them in other ways, such as providing pensions to the families of ‘martyrs’ and selectively commemorating  violent events. So, I definitely think that is happening, but at the same time this issue is still quite unsettled.

For instance, I was recently in Timor for some group discussions with families of the disappeared and missing. One theme came out clearly: the absence of the bodies of the deceased remains an unresolved issue for many families, who need to find the remains of their loved ones so that they can give them a proper burial. As I write about in The Unruly Dead, death rituals are incredibly important in Timor because they help to facilitate the spirit’s transition to the ancestral realm. And this is especially important in cases where people died violent or “bad” deaths. If people cannot perform mortuary rituals they are left with a sense of unfulfilled obligations to their ancestors, a sense that the dead are not yet at rest. And this is sometimes felt to have an impact on intergenerational well-being. There remains a tension, therefore, between the state’s attempt to co-opt the dead into the national narrative and this unsettled business around spirits. 

However, one thing I also noticed on my recent visit is that there is now a new generation of Timorese young people who did not live through the Indonesian occupation, and who have very different priorities from the older generation. It will be interesting to see whether young people will continue to feel that the past remains unsettled.

JURIST: Members of the 12 November committee, which represents over 2000 survivors of the Santa Cruz massacre and families of those who died, sometimes refer to themselves as the Mate Restu (a Tetum phrase meaning “the remaining ones of the dead“). You write in The Unruly Dead that the Mate Restu have a moral authority that makes them “difficult to ignore by the political elite.” But you also describe their memory-work as “neither wholly resistant to the state nor completely supportive of its policies.” How does that tension play out now that they are more involved in official commemorations? Has their moral authority shifted, or does being closer to power give them more say?

Professor Kent: Yes, I do think that it does bring them closer to power. One of the things that I have noticed with the annual Santa Cruz commemoration is that over the years it has become bigger, and is now funded by the state. The story of the massacre has become incorporated by the state as part of its national story. The date of the massacre is now designated National Youth Day, so this very nationalist sort of celebration. Around the time of commemoration, there are a lot of talk shows on the radio where survivors of the massacre talk about the lessons from Santa Cruz for young people of today; these lessons are often about how they should be more organized,  and work hard for the development of Timor-Leste. In this way,  the memory of Santa Cruz has become a sort of pedagogical or moral lesson for young people of today about the importance of youth sacrifice, discipline, hard work and nationalism.

So, I would say that as the 12 November committee has become increasingly successful in terms of ascribing a national significance to the Santa Cruz massacre and gaining increased state resources for the commemorations, there are questions about whether this has dampened its criticism of government policies. The 12 November committee does not appear to be engaged in public action or direct protests that demand prosecutions or push for  Indonesia to reveal where the bodies of the victims are. That said, it is highly likely that conversations with the Timorese government are happening behind closed doors as the issue of finding the bodies of the Santa Cruz victims remains so important for many families.

JURIST: The argument in The Unruly Dead is that memory works at different levels—national, local, intimate—and that outside of official spaces—for instance in homes, neighbourhoods, and through practices of communicating with the spirit realm—we can see that Santa Cruz means something beyond its national story. But families’ most urgent needs still have not been met, decades on. So, what does holding onto those practices actually achieve, and does celebrating the intimate level risk letting the state off the hook?

Professor Kent: I think what I am trying to draw out in my work is that there are multiple things going on at the same time when it comes to Santa Cruz. If we focus only on the annual commemoration in Dili, we see a very nationalist event that is perhaps not very critical of the state, but if we focus on the intimate, we see a more unsettled picture emerging, one in which it is evident that people are still concerned about finding the remains of their loved ones and giving them a proper burial. So I guess what I am suggesting is that it is important to recognize that the massacre can hold different meanings to different people and that one person can also hold in tension their own multiple meanings. 

Focusing on the intimate realm does not mean giving up on the responsibilities of the Timor-Leste and Indonesian states (and the western states that condoned or ignored the massacre). Instead, it shows that things are less resolved than they may appear. The other thing I discuss in The Unruly Dead is how people are going out looking for the remains of their loved ones and engaging in  practices of calling their restless spirits when bodies cannot be found. These practices show us that families’ needs have not been met and that people are trying the best they can to meet their own needs. In fact, I think families of Santa Cruz victims have become very frustrated with the state and the international community. They feel like they need to find their own pathways because they have not received assistance or information that might help them locate the remains of their loved ones. There was one international initiative – the International Forensic Team – that came to Timor to try to find the remains of the Santa Cruz victims, but in the end, they only found a very small number of people. In a way, this initiative raised people’s expectations without really being able to deliver on them.

JURIST: Access to these intimate spaces is largely dependent on two decades of building trust with the 12 November committee, local NGOs and ordinary East Timorese. There is a tension between a scholar’s duty to analyze these practices and the risk that the analysis could undercut the political claims of the communities involved. How is that tension navigated?

Professor Kent: I see it as my responsibility as a scholar to examine the complexity of what is going on. And that means exploring what is happening publicly—for instance, activist movements for justice and public commemorations—while also seeking to understand what is less visible, for instance what families are doing in their everyday lives, which can be equally important to questions of politics, memory, and social repair. I think that drawing these multiple strands together can help us to gain a fuller picture of the meanings of the Santa Cruz massacre today.

For example, in terms of public activism, I think there is less emphasis now than there used to be on prosecutions, although there are still organizations pushing for that. I know there are also ongoing efforts to persuade the Timor-Leste government to ratify the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance and to establish, with Indonesia, a bilateral commission on missing persons. Given the Timor-Leste state’s emphasis on rebuilding relations with Indonesia, it has not been very proactive on these issues.

My research also suggests that human rights advocacy has not always focused on families’ most urgent priorities.  For example, in the early years after independence, there was a great deal of focus by activists on the need for prosecutions of perpetrators, including of those involved in the Santa Cruz massacre. While not to discount the importance of prosecutions, my research suggests that finding and reburying the remains of the dead, or finding ways to settle restless spirits (in cases where remains cannot be found) is perhaps the more important issue for many families.

The recovery and reburial of the dead is also important to the state. This is evident in the ongoing efforts to locate the body of former resistance leader Nicolau Lobato, who was killed by the Indonesian military in the early years of the occupation. Discussions between the Timor-Leste and Indonesian governments on this issue continue, even if, by all accounts, the Timorese government has not been very proactive.