Brazil’s Election Shows Organized Voters Can Beat the Algorithm Commentary
Brazil’s Election Shows Organized Voters Can Beat the Algorithm

People have an understanding of many things they haven’t yet experienced, things they know from hearsay or brief reading. People have a tenuous, reasonable, or profound understanding of some things and subjects. Of Saturn’s rings; of watching the Super Bowl live; of driving a Formula 1 car; of how AI works; of Stephen Curry’s three-point shots; of a “Tropicália” concert; of the banquets of Louis XVI’s France and Marie Antoinette’s “let them eat brioche,” a line that in truth first appears in Rousseau’s Confessions.

The world, and consequently the people of the world, have some understanding of Brazil: forests, football, beaches, a gigantic territory, cheerful people, and many people. Samba and Bossa Nova. On the other hand, the world, and many people in the world, have no idea about the solidity of democracy in Brazil, about how technologically advanced the Brazilian electoral system is, how we conduct elections, and especially how we count votes quickly and securely.

After a long period of military dictatorship, which lasted from 1964 to 1985, Brazil rediscovered democracy, convening a National Constituent Assembly that drafted a democratic, republican, and federative constitution with a broad charter of human and social rights. Since 1989, it has held free and democratic presidential elections on schedule, every four years since a 1994 constitutional amendment shortened the presidential term from five years. The most recent election, on Oct. 25, 2026, re-elected Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva to a fourth term. He defeated Sen. Flávio Bolsonaro in the runoff after trailing him in the first round on Oct. 4. “Lula,” as he is known worldwide, ran for president for the first time in 1989, precisely the year in which Brazil truly returned to direct presidential elections. He was not victorious in 1989, and ran again, unsuccessfully, in the 1994 and 1998 elections. On his fourth attempt, in 2002, he was successful, a feat he repeated in 2006, 2022, and now in 2026.

Lula is a political phenomenon that history will define more precisely. Meanwhile, what is certain and undeniable is that the 2026 Brazilian election is a lesson to the world, a statement made without jingoism or exaggeration, based on facts.

It is a fact that Brazilian law bars companies from donating to campaigns at all and caps individual donations at 10% of the donor’s gross income from the year before the election. In the United States, by contrast, the Supreme Court’s 2010 decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission struck down limits on independent political spending by corporations and unions, though direct contributions to candidates remain capped. Obviously, the system is not immune to unaccounted-for money in a given campaign, but when it occurs it is isolated, subject to legal sanctions, and in no way comparable to the sums spent in the United States.

The Tsunami in the Streets and the Defeat of the Algorithm

It is a fact that Brazilian streets were taken over by gigantic popular waves, especially between the first and second rounds of the presidential election. In the case of the winning campaign, Lula’s, the tsunami of people in the streets leads to two important and interconnected reflections: (1) there was an immense, genuine popular mobilization, without the need for incentives of any kind, such as the campaign concerts (showmícios) that were common in Brazil until a 2006 law banned them, or the $1 million-a-day payouts Elon Musk’s America PAC offered voters in closely contested states who signed its petition during the 2024 US presidential election. Brazilian legislation would never allow that. (2) internet users mobilized en masse even as pro-Lula posts lost reach on social networks, notably Meta’s Facebook and Instagram—a drop Lula’s campaign challenged before Brazil’s Superior Electoral Court as interference, and which Meta blamed on technical problems while denying that it favored his opponent.

And here’s the question: were the streets taken over despite the reduced reach on some social networks, or partly because of it, as a response to it? The definitive answer requires time, analysis, and reflection. Whatever it may be, what is certain is that the popular will prevailed over technology.

However, there is one certainty, palpable, evident, and clear. Organization, political activism, the fear of darkness and regression, propelled engaged voters to choose the political option that defends the preservation of the Amazon; that seeks to combine agribusiness with sustainable environmental policies; that combats femicide; that respects gender identity; that seeks to maintain sovereignty and mineral wealth; that advocates for gun control; that wants a security policy without relativizing rights and freedoms; that calls for investment in public health and education; that seeks to preserve the Separation and Division of Powers and respect for judicial decisions and the will of the ballot box.

In this sense, the tsunamis that swept through the streets of Brazil and the victory of candidate Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva are robust and unequivocal demonstrations that the popular will defeated the algorithm, and did so with engagement and determination. This has importance far beyond Brazil.

João Carlos Souto, Professor of Constitutional Law, PhD in Law, visiting researcher at the Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law (Heidelberg, Germany, 2025), Attorney of the National Treasury. He is the author of Suprema Corte dos Estados Unidos — Principais Decisões (Supreme Court of the United States — Main Decisions) (1st ed. 2008, 4th ed. 2021), considered the main reference on American law in Brazilian courts and academia. The 2021 final report of the Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court of the United States, created by President Joe Biden to analyze the debate over Supreme Court reform, cited a submission he wrote on behalf of the Instituto Brasil Estados Unidos de Direito Comparado, which he founded and chairs.

Opinions expressed in JURIST Commentary are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of JURIST's editors, staff, donors or the University of Pittsburgh.