 |
|

Legal news from Thursday, June 16, 2005 |
 |
|


States brief ~ GA high court warns about jury instructions on eyewitness evidence
Rachel Felton on June 16, 2005 5:20 PM ET

[JURIST] Leading Thursday's states brief, the Supreme Court of Georgia has warned criminal trial judges to be careful in the way they instruct juries about weighing the value of eyewitness identification. In a decision [PDF text] today, the Court said "We can no longer endorse an instruction authorizing jurors to consider the witness's certainty in his/her identification as a factor to be used in deciding the reliability of that identification" and warned trial courts not to do so. The ruling overturned an armed robbery conviction in which the trial judge instructed the jury to consider the witness's certainty as a factor to decide the reliability of the identification. The only evidence against the defendant was two-eyewitness identifications. AP has more.
In other state legal news ... - Vermont State Attorney General William H. Sorrell has asked the US Supreme Court to review [press release] whether the state's campaign finance reform law is constitutional. In a decision earlier this year, the US Second Circuit Court of Appeals [official website] ruled that Vermont can limit spending on all state races. The ruling was the first in the nation to hold spending limits as constitutional and not a violation of a candidate's First Amendment right to free speech. The law was supposed to become effective in 2000, but has been put on hold pending appeals. Rutland Herald has local coverage.
- A federal district court has ruled that Maryland can proceed with its plans to start killing mute swans, ending a two year challenge from some animal-rights groups. The Maryland Department of Natural Resources wants to kill the swans because of their negative impact on the environment [DNR Mute Swan Management Plan]. Two years ago when animal rights groups first challenged the DNR's right to kill the swans, US District Judge Emmet G. Sullivan found in favor of the animal rights groups. Last year, however, a Maryland Representative placed language into a federal spending bill that essentially removed the swans from protection under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act [text]. In his opinion [PDF text], Judge Sullivan said, "The record in this case indicates that Congress did express clear intent to exclude non-native species, including mute swans, from the protections afforded to other migratory birds by the Conventions and the MBTA." The Humane Society has not ruled out further lawsuits to prevent Maryland from killing the mute swans. The Baltimore Sun has local coverage.
- Pennsylvania Governor Ed Rendell [official website] has signed into law [press release] a bill that provides immunity from civil liability for employers who disclose the work histories of current or former employees. The work history information must be requested by the employee or a prospective new employer. The bill [text] allows employees or former employees to sue if they can show that the employer or former employee did not act in good faith. AP has more.


Link |
|
subscribe |
|
latest newscast |
archive |
Facebook page

|

International brief ~ Zimbabwe evictions appealed to African human rights body
D. Wes Rist on June 16, 2005 4:05 PM ET

[JURIST] Leading Thursday's international brief, Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights [Zim Human Rights Forum backgrounder] have filed an official appeal with the African Commission for Human and Peoples' Rights [official website], the regional human rights body in Africa, to intervene in the continuing mass evictions authorized by Zimbabwe President Robert Mugabe [Wikipedia profile] and prevent further evictions and the destruction of informal traders' places of business. ZLHR had previously filed suit [JURIST report] against the Zimbawean government for allegedly violating the Zimbabwean Constitution to carry out the mass evictions. The evictions program, defended by Mugabe as 'necessary to clean up the streets and cities of Zimbabwe,' has been severely criticized by the European Union, the United Nations, Amnesty International, the UK, and the US, as well as numerous international and local human rights and religious groups. The ACHPR has the power only to make recommendations to member governments and cannot enforce its decisions concerning government actions. JURIST's Paper Chase has continuing coverage of Zimbabwe [JURIST news archive]. ZimOnline has local coverage.
In a related development in Zimbabwe, the Bulawayo Upcoming Traders Association has succeded in getting a local High Court to schedule a hearing for an injunctive relief case against Bulawayo Police Commissioner Augustine Chihuri in order to force him to cease the destruction of the places of business of informal traders in the Zimbabwean city. Counsel for the Traders Association, Robert Ndlovu, is arguing that the evictions are illegal as the traders had been properly licensed under Bulawayo [official website] municipal bylaws, and that the police carrying out the evictions failed to follow proper procedure in enforcing the eviction notices, thereby invalidating the process. The hearing is scheduled for early next week. ZimOnline has local coverage.
In other international legal news ... - The National Electoral Board of Ethiopia [government website] has announced that it will be investigating the circumstances surrounding voting in around 200 of the nation's 524 parliamentary seats that were open for election in light of complaints filed by both ruling and opposition party officials. Ethiopia has been rocked by increasing violence [JURIST report] during protests against alleged fraud [JURIST report] during the 15 May national elections, the first of four elections designed to reintroduce a democratic government in the nation for the first time in decades. The electoral board annonced that over 20 teams would be set up to investigate the allegations, which range from simple voter fraud to violent intimidation of voters by soldiers carrying automatic weapons. The NEB has invited observers from African Union, the European Union, and the Carter Center to oversee the process. A breakdown of the exact number of contested seats and their locations is scheduled to be released Friday. The Sudan Tribune has local coverage.
- Chairman Samuel Kivuitu of the Electoral Commission of Kenya [government website] warned Wednesday that the current structure of the Constitution of Kenya Review (Amendment) Act 2004 [official text] is insufficently detailed to allow for a smooth review and eventual adoption of a new constitution for Kenya. Chief among his complaints was the lack of a Referendum Act in the CKRA that clearly defined the process for conducting the national referendum required by the CKRA to implement a new constitution. Kivuitu warned that the CKRA was silent on who was allowed to participate in the referendum (the act only refers to the 'people of Kenya'), what procedures would be implemented for monitoring and observing the process to ensure fair and impartial voting, and what role the judicial branch would have in deciding any legal challenges to the referendum. The Constitution of Kenya Review Commission [government website] has yet to set a timeline for the likely introduction of a detailed information concerning the proposed changes to the current constitution [official text]. JURIST's Paper Chase has continuing coverage of Kenya [JURIST news archive]. Kenya's Daily Nation has local coverage.


Link |
|
subscribe |
|
latest newscast |
archive |
Facebook page

|

US supports expanding UN Security Council
Tom Henry on June 16, 2005 1:10 PM ET

[JURIST] The US government Thursday publicly expressed support for expanding the UN Security Council [offcial website] by "two or so" permanent members, saying that a larger expansion could hinder the effectiveness of the group. Review the State Department briefing [transcript] by US Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs R. Nicholas Burns. UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan proposed expansion in his March Larger Freedom [text] report to the UN, and the so-called G-4 group - Japan, Brazil, India and Germany - presented a draft resolution for Council expansion last month, although the US has not specifically endorsed that proposal or the candidacy of all of those states. There are currently five permanent members of the Security Council - the US, Britain, France, China, and Russia - all of which have veto power. The US does not support veto power for new permanent members. US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice [official website] has expressed US support for Japan, the second largest financial contributor to the UN behind the US, as a permanent Council member. AP has more.


Link |
|
subscribe |
|
latest newscast |
archive |
Facebook page

|

US panel calls for UN reform as funding dispute looms
David Shucosky on June 16, 2005 9:18 AM ET

[JURIST] The Task Force on the United Nations [official site], a bipartisan group created by the US Congress in December 2004, released a report [text] Wednesday calling for significant changes in the UN, a number of which echo proposals advanced by the world body itself [JURIST report]. The recommendations include restructuring leadership positions and powers, creating an oversight board to fight corruption, and abolishing the UN Human Rights Commission [official website] while replacing it with a Human Rights Council "whose members are democracies dedicated to protecting human rights". In a statement, UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan said he welcomed the report [press release]. Rep. Henry Hyde [official website], (R-IL), chairman of the House International Relations Committee, introduced a UN reform bill on June 7 that would allow the US to withhold UN dues if changes were not made [JURIST report]. But the Bush administration has now told Congress it opposes that legislation, saying that it would undermine American credibility and effectiveness [Washington Post report]. The Boston Globe has more.


Link |
|
subscribe |
|
latest newscast |
archive |
Facebook page

|
| For more legal news check the Paper Chase Archive...
|
|
|