However, the violence continued in the following years and has become more complex. Not only have the attacks from the government continued, but presence of groups such as the Islamic State has increased the death toll in Syria. According to the UN, hundreds of thousands of Syrians have been killed and millions of others have been displaced. The UN continues to call on Assad and other countries in the region to help end the violence and find a political soluation.
To quell the rising tide of civilian unrest, Assad announced on March 25, 2011, that the country's 48-year-old state of emergency law would be lifted, and human rights issues would be addressed by the government. The emergency law included a ban on political protest. Government officials hinted that Assad would be willing to make other concessions, such as releasing political prisoners, allowing the creation of new political parties and increasing government employee salaries. These measures were viewed as an attempt to quiet civilian unrest. Assad's announcement came days after 36 protesters were killed by police and other protesters were arrested. Civilian protests escalated into violence in late March 2011, when protesters set fire to a police station and local Baath party headquarters. The Syrian government then released 260 political detainees to appease the protesters.
Emergency rule officially ended on April 21, 2011. Although that action legalized peaceful protests, the Syrian government requested that civilians discontinue the rebellions. Students continued to openly protest against the government, and security forces responded with aggressive action. On April 22, 2011, Syrian security forces opened fire on a peaceful crowd of protesters, killing more than 75. The UN Human Rights Council (UNHRC) estimated on April 29, 2011, that 500 protesters had been killed by security forces since March 2011. By June 2011, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Navi Pillay, estimated that the number of protesters killed had increased to approximately 1,100 while 10,000 people had been placed in detention.
In a speech at Damascus University on June 20, 2011, Assad claimed that an unidentified group of terrorists was responsible for the vandalism, robberies and murders plaguing the country. Assad also accused the international media of manipulating civilians and instigating rebellion in the hopes of achieving better video footage. Assad urged citizens to participate in new government reforms, including the creation of a new constitution, instead of continuing to protest. However, civilian demonstrations continued, and AI reported in August 2011 that over 88 detained protesters had been tortured and then killed in custody.
On November 4, 2011, the Syrian government classified the country's protesters as "insurgents" and stated that those who had revolted against the government could possibly qualify for amnesty if they turned themselves in to authorities by November 12, 2011. The frequency and intensity of the protests did not diminish, and the UN Committee Against Torture accused Syrian security forces of detaining and torturing children. Civilian protests were divided between violent and nonviolent activism, and on December 15, 2011, the Syrian army opened fire on a group of unarmed protesters. While the army turned to increasing violence against protesters as a method of enforcement, the government continued to release detainees as a means of appeasement. Over 552 detainees were released on January, 8, 2012. However, human rights groups estimated that as of January 2012, approximately 37,000 additional detainees remained imprisoned.
On February 26, 2012, the Syrian government held a referendum on whether to adopt a new constitution. Civilian protests continued up until the vote, and 89 people were killed the day before the referendum. Although many international organizations feared that the referendum was an empty gesture, hope remained that new provisions for freedom of speech, press, assembly and association would help quiet the rebellion.
Both peaceful and violent rebellions continued into the spring of 2012, and HRW released a report stating that security forces had escalated from using violence to halt protests to summarily executing protesters. HRW estimated that over 100 civilians and Syrian opposition fighters had been executed during attacks in late March and early April 2012. Over 80 women and children were shot at close range on May 29, 2012.
Detainee releases continued as a means of placating protesters. Over 500 prisoners were released in May 2012. The government formally announced the prisoner releases on June 1, 2012, following outcry over the May 29 massacre. As pressure from citizens and the international community increased, Assad denied that the government had any involvement with the May 29 massacre. He instead blamed foreign extremists and terrorists.
Amid concerns that the Syrian army and security forces were using sexual violence against detainees, Assad agreed to a peace plan on July 9, 2012, brokered by UN Joint Special Envoy Kofi Annan. The plan outlined steps for ending the violence, allowing access to humanitarian and human rights groups and encouraging political dialogue. However, security forces continued to attack protesters, with 200 civilians massacred on July 15, 2012. The UN suggested in June 2012 that over 850,000 Syrian citizens were receiving food assistance and over 100,000 had been displaced from their homes.
By fall 2012, increasing violence could be blamed on both the Syrian government and rebel forces. UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon stated that, as of September 2012, over 1.2 million people had been displaced from their homes and 225,000 refugees had fled to surrounding nations.
The conflict continued to escalate, and the UN released proof in November 2012 that rebel forces had been summarily executing captured and surrendered Syrian soldiers. The UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights estimated in January 2013 that approximately 60,000 people had been killed since the conflict began in March 2011, although the death toll is likely to increase as better estimates are received. In March 2013, human rights organizations accused the Syrian government of using banned cluster bombs and chemical weapons against civilians.
In May 2013, the Syrian government killed up to 100 people in the village of Bayda. In August 2013, rockets filled with chemical agents were fired around Damascus, killing hundreds of people. The US and its allies blamed the Syrian government for those attacks, and as a result, Assad agreed with the UN and the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons to destroy Syria's chemical weapon arsenal. However, chemical attacks occurred again between April and July 2014 in villages in northern Syria. In January 2014, the government of Qatar released a report that details the "systematic torture and killing of detained persons by the agents of the Syrian government" and suggests that the Syrian government had committed "war crimes" and "crimes against humanity." Furthermore, in November 2015, Amnesty International released a report detailing how the Syrian government has concealed the whereabouts of 58,000 civilian detainees who suffer from torture, disease, and eventually death.
Prior to the instigation of the current conflict in March 2011, Assad was already a controversial figure internationally. In the past, he has been accused of human rights violations for imprisoning individuals with opposing viewpoints and was called on by HRW, the Arab League, the US and the UN to release political prisoners. During the UN's probe into the assassination of former Lebanese president Rafik Hariri, Assad continually rejected requests that he submit to questioning and ignored international pressures to cooperate with the investigation. There is still international speculation that Syria was involved in the assassination. Assad was also criticized by the UN and other members of the international community for his perceived involvement in the Lebanese presidential election in 2004 and the stationing of thousands of troops in Lebanon during that time, as well as for stunting economic growth in Syria and corruption within his administration.
The Arab League
Fellow Arab League states initially stood behind Assad and supported his government as the conflict began. However, this support diminished as the conflict continued to grow and threatened stability in the region. In October 2011, the Arab League denounced the violence in Syria and called for its resolution. The next month, the League voted to suspend Syria's membership due to the Assad regime's violence against protesters. This vote came as a surprise to many in the international community given that Syria was one of the founding nations of the Arab League. The vote was 18 in favor of the sanction, with only Lebanon, Yemen and Syria voting against it and Iraq abstaining. As a result of this vote, all Arab League nations were instructed to remove their ambassadors from Damascus. This action was viewed as effectively isolating Assad in the region with many longstanding allies voting against his regime.
In December 2011, Syria agreed to allow Arab League observers to monitor protests as part of a peace plan. As a result, in January 2012, Syrian leaders released 552 prisoners. Although further pressure was put on the Arab League by HRW and other groups to push Syria for more action to resolve the conflict quickly and peacefully, all of the observers, beginning with those from Saudi Arabia, withdrew by the end of January 2012. The Arab League's General Secretary, Nabil el-Araby, cited "the critical deterioration of the situation" as the promulgating reason in a statement.
In January 2013, Saudi Arabia and Egypt, the largest economies and most populous nations in the Arab League, issued a joint call for a peaceful handover of power from Assad to the opposition. "A peaceful exit is an Arab and international demand," Saudi Foreign Minister Prince Saud Al-Faisal said to reporters in Riyadh on January 5, 2013.
The United Nations
In September 2011, the UNHRC established the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry on Syria to investigate human rights abuses during the conflict. This group released a report in February 2013 that cited war crimes on both sides of the conflict, including indiscriminate attacks in areas causing civilian casualties and destruction of civilian entities, such as hospitals. Although the Commission was not permitted to conduct interviews inside the nation by the Syrian government, they were able to conduct 445 interviews over two years:
The depth of the Syrian tragedy is poignantly reflected in the accounts of its victims. Their harrowing experiences of survival detail grave human rights violations, war crimes and crimes against humanity. The destructive dynamics of the civil war not only have an impact on the civilian population but are also tearing apart the country's complex social fabric, jeopardizing future generations and undermining peace and security in the entire region.Also in February 2013, the UN Secretary-General on Sexual Violence in Conflict Zainab Hawa Bangura expressed concern regarding sexual violence on both sides of the conflict. She stated, "The people of Syria continue to suffer greatly. Civilians already caught in a vicious cycle of violence are also the target of sexual violence by all parties to the conflict."
In October 2013, the UN entered a joint mission with the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW) to dismantle Syria's chemical weapons program. The mission completed operations in September 2014.
In December 2013, the UN General Assembly adopted a resolution urging the UN Security Council to combat ongoing human rights violations in Syria. On December 18, 2015, the UN Security Council agreed to a plan focused on assisting a political transition in Syria. The resolution called for ceasefire, a new constitution and elections facilitated by the UN.
The UNHCR has been increasingly involved in providing humanitarian aid to refugees and other displaced persons fleeing the conflict. In 2015, efforts focused on providing basic needs, improving and maintaining shelters, protecting against and responding to sexual violence, and resettling refugees.
The US first spoke out against Assad's actions against protesters early in the conflict. US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton expressed deep concerns over Assad's actions in an opinion piece that ran in Asharq Al-Awsat, an Arabic newspaper based out of London, on June 17, 2011. In the article, Clinton stated, "It is increasingly clear that President Assad has made his choice. But while continued brutality may allow him to delay the change that is underway in Syria, it will not reverse it."
In August 2011, US President Barack Obama issued a statement outlining a series of sanctions and other actions being taken against Syria by the US Departments of the Treasury and Commerce, which effectively froze all US-controlled Syrian assets and prohibited US entities from doing business with Syria. In a statement issued the same day, President Obama echoed a similar sentiment of support for the opposition against Assad as that had been offered earlier by Clinton:
The future of Syria must be determined by its people, but President Bashar al-Assad is standing in their way. His calls for dialogue and reform have rung hollow while he is imprisoning, torturing and slaughtering his own people. We have consistently said that President Assad must lead a democratic transition or get out of the way. He has not led. For the sake of the Syrian people, the time has come for President Assad to step aside.In April 2012, President Obama issued an executive order allowing for sanctions against foreign nationals who use technology to violate human rights. In the order, he specifically targeted Assad and subsequently used the order as justification to issue further sanctions against Syria. The US Department of State (DOS) continues to emphasize the US's commitment to humanitarian aid in Syria, and in June 2013 President Obama pledged to allocate over $300 million in aid.
The White House issued a statement in response to videos showing chemical weapon attacks on Syrian civilians in August 2013. President Obama confirmed in September 2013 that the US would continue working with Russia towards eliminating Syria's chemical weapons program.
As resettlement efforts for displaced Syrians progress, public anxiety about security concerns grows. While the US continues to receive refugees, the Department of State has emphasized a rigorous screening for all incoming refugees to eliminate potential threats.
Russia was one of Assad's strongest allies both before the conflict began in Spring 2011 and during it. In addition, Russia, as one of only five nations with permanent veto power in the UN Security Council, vowed to veto any sanctions brought against Assad in the UN. This vow led to the veto of the first three resolutions that were brought before the UNSC to condemn the actions of Assad. China joined Russia in opposition of Assad and vetoed the same three proposed resolutions. The US and Turkey, among other nations, claim that Russia is currently assisting Assad by providing him weapons and other tactical support. Russian leaders deny any support on their part and the country's Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev stated in November 2012:
Our stance on Syria is well known: Russia does not support anyone in this conflict ... We only tell them that they must sit down at the negotiating table and come to an agreement, rather than shoot at each other, which is the worst possible scenario. But unfortunately, some countries have a more one-sided approach: this one must leave immediately, and we will send weapons to the other ones. We believe that this is not right, that this will never bring peace to Syria.
6/14/2013: UN rights council condemned foreign military involvement in Syria
6/13/2013: UN rights office announced that Syria death toll had reached at least 93,000
6/4/2013: UN panel reported that war crimes were escalating in Syria
6/1/2013: UN Secretary General called for protection of civilians in Syria
5/29/2013: UN rights council condemned Syria attacks, foreign fighters
5/27/2013: UN human rights chief criticized rights violations in Syria
5/17/2013: HRW found evidence of torture, arbitrary detention in Syria government centers...[more]